Shih Tzu Emotions vs. Instincts: What Your Dog Really Feels

A dog’s core feelings are real. He is born able to feel them, the same way he is born with his nose. What he is not born with is any…

Ara HugheyAra HugheyCertified Tier II Puppy Evaluator

Oct 21, 2026
A small dog wearing a bow tie next to pink balloons.

From the Divine Pups blog

A dog’s core feelings are real. He is born able to feel them, the same way he is born with his nose. What he is not born with is any of the complicated stuff we carry around on top of our feelings, and the size of that gap explains more of a dog’s behavior than almost anything else we could teach him.

Understanding Shih Tzu emotions vs. instincts changes how you look at your own dog, whether he’s a Shih Tzu puppy still figuring out the world or a grown dog you’ve lived with for years.

Shih Tzu Emotions vs. Instincts: Why They’re Not the Same Thing

An instinct is something a dog is born already knowing how to do. A feeling is the state he’s in while he’s doing it. He comes with both, and only one of them changes over the course of his life. Instincts stay fixed. Feelings shift constantly, shaped by what’s actually happening around him in a given moment.

The Shih Tzu Emotions That Are Real

A dog genuinely feels a specific set of core emotions:

  • Fear
  • Anxiety
  • Frustration
  • Excitement
  • Joy
  • Pleasure
  • Love
  • Grief

Every one of those is real, not projected onto him by us. That’s not the complete list of everything he experiences, but it’s the honest core of it.

The Human Emotions Your Shih Tzu Does Not Feel

Here’s the part that surprises people. A dog does not feel:

  • Guilt, shame, pride, or embarrassment
  • Remorse, spite, revenge, or malice
  • Contempt or ambition
  • Resentment, bitterness, disdain, or humiliation
  • Self-righteousness, entitlement, cynicism, smugness, or grudges
  • A fear of being misunderstood

None of that shows up in a dog, anywhere. All of it is ours, the layer we add on top of a much simpler animal underneath.

Is Your Shih Tzu Jealous? What That Label Really Means

This is the question I get asked more than almost any other, and the honest answer is that jealous is one lazy word covering several completely different dogs. One dog pushes in when attention goes elsewhere. Another watches from a distance. A third joins right in without any friction at all. Those are three different states, and jamming all of them under a single label tells you nothing useful about what’s actually happening for the dog in front of you.

Why Your Shih Tzu’s Guilty Look Isn’t Guilt

That famous guilty look isn’t guilt. It’s a dog reading our energy and trying to make peace with it, not confessing to a crime he understands he committed. He’s responding to how upset we already are, not to some internal sense of wrongdoing about what he did earlier.

How Understanding Shih Tzu Emotions Changes Your Training

Obedience on its own never fixes a feeling. Changing the state underneath it does. Fear is not disobedience, and a Shih Tzu who loses it at the vacuum isn’t being stubborn. He’s genuinely afraid, and no amount of “sit” is going to touch that fear directly. You have to address the feeling itself, not just the behavior sitting on top of it.

The Deepest Emotional Need Every Shih Tzu Has

A dog is built to bond, and to feel real pain when he’s left alone. Meeting that need takes a steady parent figure, someone he can orient around, not a set of commands he’s expected to follow regardless of how he feels.

How to Respond to Your Shih Tzu’s Emotions Instead of Just His Behavior

Once you know a behavior is coming from a real feeling rather than a human motive like spite or guilt, responding gets simpler:

  • Name the feeling first, out loud if it helps (“he’s scared,” not “he’s being bad”).
  • Address the environment or trigger causing the feeling, rather than only correcting the behavior it produces.
  • Offer comfort or distance for fear and anxiety, not correction, since those states aren’t disobedience.
  • Give excitement and joy a real outlet, rather than trying to suppress them outright.
  • Stay steady and predictable, since that consistency is what a Shih Tzu’s need to bond is actually asking for.

The Science Behind Shih Tzu Emotions vs. Instincts

None of this is a guess. Decades of work mapping the mammal brain keep turning up the same handful of deep emotional systems: the drive to seek and explore, fear, anger, the pull to care for young, the distress of being left alone, and the urge to play. Nobody sits a puppy down and teaches him to want his mother (Panksepp, 1998 and 2011).

The bond itself has been measured directly. Researchers borrowed a test originally built to study human babies and their mothers and ran it with dogs instead. A dog explores more when his person is in the room, looks for them when they’re gone, and sticks with a difficult puzzle longer when they’re present (TopĆ”l and colleagues, 1998, replicated independently since).

And the guilty look really isn’t guilt. In the study everyone argues about, the look tracked whether the owner was upset, not whether the dog had actually done anything wrong. The biggest guilty looks of all came from dogs that had done nothing at all and got scolded anyway (Horowitz, 2009).

The One Thing to Remember About Shih Tzu Emotions

A dog feels emotions. He just doesn’t think about them the way we do. We add the guilt and the grudges. A dog just feels.

Your Shih Tzu Emotions Practice for This Week

For the next few days, catch yourself the moment you reach for a label. Jealous. Stubborn. Guilty. Spiteful. Stop, and answer two questions instead. What did he actually do, and how did he seem to feel while he was doing it? Write both down. What you’ll usually find is that one label has been sitting on top of three or four completely different dogs

author avatar
Ara Hughey
Filed under: Dog Behavior · New Owner

Free guide

The 12 temperament traits, explained

Know what to look for before you fall in love with a photo.

Two minutes

Which temperament fits your home?

Take the quiz and know your match before the photos arrive.

Ara Hughey

Written by

Ara Hughey

Ara raises Shih Tzus in Houston, Texas, and writes about temperament, development and the small daily things that make a good match. Every puppy is born with a divine purpose.

Not sure yet?

Find the temperament that fits your life

The quiz takes two minutes and tells you exactly what to look for.

Ready to meet them?

See who’s ready to come home

Every puppy has a health record and a temperament score.

Keep reading

More from the blog